Reproductive success

Reproductive success of Baltic herring

The reproductive success of Baltic herring depends on fertilisation and on the survival of eggs and larvae. Our research in the Archipelago Sea shows that both the environment, such as salinity, temperature and the spawning substrate, and the traits of the parent fish affect how many eggs develop into larvae.

How does salinity affect herring reproduction?

Baltic herring are highly adaptable and spawn throughout the Baltic Sea, even in areas with nearly freshwater conditions. Herring eggs can be fertilised across a wide range of salinities. In experiments, fertilisation success was highest at about 8 PSU (practical salinity units).

Female herring. Photo: Johannes Sahlsten

What threatens herring eggs?

The time from fertilisation to hatching varies from a few days to several weeks, depending on water temperature. During this period, the eggs are vulnerable to many threats. They are eaten by fish such as perch and whitefish, which are common in the Archipelago Sea.

The spawning substrate also affects egg survival. In our field studies, less than 5 % of the eggs attached to Cladophora and Potamogeton died, whereas mortality on red algae (Furcellaria, Phyllophora) exceeded 50 % (Rajasilta et al. 1989). Experiments confirmed higher egg mortality on Furcellaria than on Cladophora (Rajasilta et al. 2006). Some algae release substances that are toxic to the eggs, so the composition of the plant community on the spawning beds affects reproductive success.

How do the parent fish affect offspring survival?

Reproductive success depends not only on environmental conditions but also on the traits of the parent fish. Experiments have shown differences between females in fertilisation rate and embryonic survival, and differences between males in fertilisation success (Laine 1999). In some cases, the offspring of the least successful females had only 10 % of the survival of the offspring of the most successful females.

Female size and condition are particularly important. Larger females generally produce eggs with better early survival. Females in better condition (heavier relative to their length) and with higher muscle fat content produced eggs with lower early mortality and higher hatching success (Laine & Rajasilta 1999). Female condition was not associated with fertilisation rate or late embryonic mortality (Table 1).

Table 1. Correlation between female properties and reproductive success.

Parameter Fertilization Rate Early Mortality Late Mortality Survival Hatching Success
Condition Factor 0.24 -0.57* -0.10 0.30 0.43*
Somatic Condition 0.38 -0.45* -0.25 0.47* 0.51*
Muscle Fat (DWt %) 0.04 -0.50* -0.17 0.41* 0.40*

*Note: Correlation coefficients marked with * are statistically significant (p < 0.003).

More recently, Mäkinen et al. (2024) showed that female size, condition, muscle fat content and ovarian thyroid hormones are associated with the properties of eggs and larvae. At higher incubation temperatures, maternal traits had an even stronger effect on offspring success. This suggests that the importance of female quality may increase as the Baltic Sea warms.

How does egg composition affect survival?

The chemical composition of the eggs affects their survival. Eggs with a higher fat content, especially polar lipids, survive better in the later stages of embryonic development. However, a high proportion of triacylglycerols (TAGs), a storage fat, can increase early embryonic mortality. This may indicate a deficiency of other yolk components needed for development.

Long-term data from the Airisto spawning population show that egg lipid content varies with environmental conditions. Egg lipid content was higher in years with higher salinity and warmer winters (Rajasilta et al. 2021). Changes in salinity and temperature may therefore affect the quality of herring eggs and, through it, recruitment.

What does this mean for the Archipelago Sea population?

Spawning herring in the Archipelago Sea are now smaller and have lower lipid reserves than in the 1980s (see Spawning population). Because fecundity, egg quality and offspring survival depend on female size and condition, these changes may reduce the reproductive success of the population, even if the number of spawners remains the same. The condition of the spawning grounds also affects reproductive success (see Spawning areas).

Related publications

  • Mäkinen, K., Rajasilta, M., Ruuskanen, S., Karpela, T., Lauerma, A., Sahlsten, J. (2024). Effects of incubation temperature and maternal phenotype on Baltic herring eggs and larvae: An experimental study. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences. Read More
  • Rajasilta, M., Mäkinen, K., Ruuskanen, S., Hänninen, J., Laine, P. (2021). Long-term data reveal the associations of egg quality with abiotic factors and female traits in Baltic herring. Frontiers in Marine Science. Read More
  • Laine, P. & Rajasilta, M. (1999). The hatching success of Baltic herring eggs and its relation to female condition. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology. Read More
  • Rajasilta, M., Laine, P. & Eklund, J. 2006. Mortality of herring eggs on different algal substrates (Furcellaria spp. and Cladophora spp.) – an experimental study. Hydrobiologia 554: 127-130. DOI 10.1007/s10750-005-1012-9. Read More
  • Laine, P. 1999. Paternal effects on the hatching success of Baltic herring eggs. ICES J. Mar. Sci. 56 (Suppl.): 142-146.
  • Laine, P. & Rajasilta, M. 1998. Changes in the reproductive properties of Baltic herring females during the spawning season. Fisheries Research 36: 67-73. Read More
  • Rajasilta, M., Paranko, J. & Laine, P. 1997. Reproductive characteristics of the male herring in the northern Baltic Sea. J. Fish. Biol. 51: 978-988. Read More
  • Rajasilta, M., Eklund, J., Kääriä, J. & Ranta-aho, K. 1989. The deposition and mortality of the eggs of the Baltic herring, Clupea harengus membras L., on different substrates in the south-west archipelago of Finland. J. Fish. Biol. 34: 417-427. Read More